Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 19:12:14 | #1  

[0|0|0|1|0] xaxaxax...good one!

unstrshpelh   | 16 июль 2010, 19:14:54 | #2  

Hmm... Look on her leg. Is it right proportions?

Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 19:24:26 | #3  

Leg's proportions? Is it too long or too what? This girl is 190sm tall. Her leg is long enough

And looking in perspective - her leg is closer to the camera.. it is normal to be bigger

whatever

unstrshpelh   | 16 июль 2010, 19:30:33 | #4  

"it is normal to be bigger" - this point of shoot and current focal range displayed her leg much massive than her body. imho

Эрадж   | 16 июль 2010, 19:33:06 | #5  

Doko - I wont be talking about technical aspects. I didn't vote for the image. I just don't like it.

It's not your best image IMHO.

Bakhriddin®   | 16 июль 2010, 19:34:31 | #6  

No Ice...

Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 19:41:56 | #7  

well...the proportion distortion due to the focal length is very well cropped - outside of the picture.. you have right (and I understand what you mean) for the "point of shoot" only, but it is what I wanted to do... perspective

So here you can see only the perspective distortion

see the original image.. much different but you will see the crop: http://img690.imageshack.us/img690/2482/dsc3979o.jpg

Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 19:47:19 | #8  

OK Eraje it is your opinion, I respect it .. but I thought we talked about when putting 1 or 2 to explain why is that.. so that we can correct it if we missed something or explain if we do wanted this "defect"

Эрадж   | 16 июль 2010, 19:51:45 | #9  

As I said I haven't vote for the image. I can explain what's wrong with photo to the absolute dummy since they're doing the same mistakes all the time. You're not dummy, I really like some your photos but not this one. I'd say I was not able to see what is the message of the photo. May be I'm just not getting it.

Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 21:35:52 | #10  

I look at the picture and I see happiness. Not because I know the moment and the person, but for the look in the eyes, the smile etc.

I see composition, I see night sky and the orange color of the sunset, I feel freedom of no engagements.

And speaking for the message of the photos .. honestly I cant see the message in most of the "week's best photo" photos, and not talking about the rest images.

Eraje, I don't get the message in this photo:
http://www.foto.tj/site/image/8801

I see grass, sky and a person with waving hair holding a "super camera" with a "super lens" .. no offend, but can you tell me what is the message?

And it is in "фото недели"

Kтонибудь   | 16 июль 2010, 21:41:43 | #11  

this foto is great, Doko, don't bother explaining why it is. People will see it!

Эрадж   | 16 июль 2010, 21:46:39 | #12  

Doko - don't be upset only because somebody do not like your photo. If I'm not getting message of your photo I do not say it's bad. It's my personal feelings about this particular image. If you're not getting my photos - that's fine with me since I take pictures for myself and the only thing I do care about - is my pleasure of photography.

As for the "Photo of the week" - it's been chosen by ordinary users not me So you'd better ask them.

MAGNUM   | 16 июль 2010, 21:55:13 | #13  

Don't see anything here...

Superdoko   | 16 июль 2010, 21:59:28 | #14  

yes Eraje, as I said I respect people's opinion, but what I am trying to say is when I see bad photo here - I leave it. I don't put 1 on it, because I don't like it. I know other people like it, I know the author has his reasons to show it. I put 1 on a photo with technical issues. And explain why I did put 1. As far as I know that's why this site is made for - educating people about photography.

I think we talked enough about it, I hope you get my idea and nobody is offended. I really like this site because I like helping people and this site is made for that.

So cheers!

unstrshpelh   | 16 июль 2010, 22:12:18 | #15  

Btw, there are not my "1" and "2" )
Anyway i wasn't impressed by this photo, but i told about my opinion without any vote-related issue.

Rustam   | 17 июль 2010, 00:47:06 | #16  

People does not like reality....If it is not as it was written in the book, it is not right some of them says.

Take it easy ) Do you really need this marks ??)) I do not think so...Specially then from 100 people may be 10 will have guts to say the truth, not thinking " Oh i need to look good in somebody's eyes" ))

P.S. She looks like 190sm , big girl

MAK   | 17 июль 2010, 02:08:48 | #17  

Superdoko, очень хорошо читает русский язык
Господа, не ломайте английский

MAK   | 17 июль 2010, 02:11:32 | #18  

да..после "Superdoko"..запятую не нужно

Olim M Shirinov   | 17 июль 2010, 03:36:39 | #19  

Skintone "-1",
Posture "-1",
Smile (mop) "-1",
Stump instead of his left hand "-1"
______
Total: 5-1-1-1-1 = 1

Olim M Shirinov   | 17 июль 2010, 05:27:40 | #20  

Sorry..., of-course "Stump instead Her left hand" )))